True College Verdict
A

Carleton College

Northfield, MN · 2,086 undergraduates · 20% receive Pell Grants · admits 20%
Private nonprofitMainly bachelor's degrees

A strong choice. It ranks 114 of 1,755 four-year colleges on student outcomes, with an overall score of 84.9 out of 100.

Is it affordable?
No
Average net price $25,295 a year after grants. Typical for similar colleges: $19,899.
Will most students finish?
Yes
91% graduate within 8 years. Typical for similar colleges: 59%.
Is it worth the price?
Likely
Graduates owe a typical $18,000 against earnings of $82,742, a ratio of 0.22. Under 0.4 is comfortable; over 0.7 is heavy.

These three answers are rules of thumb from the numbers below, not advice for any one student or major.

What do students really think?

You have seen the federal numbers for Carleton College. Now hear from people who went there, or add your own experience. Anonymous, no account.

Would you choose it again? That is the first question the rating form asks.

Why it is good

  • 91% of students graduate, better than 96% of four-year colleges.
  • It beats expectations: it graduates 23 points more students than is typical for a college enrolling the same share of low-income students (91% against an expected 69%; the estimate is rough, with a typical error of about 16 points).
  • Students stay: 97% of first-year students return for a second year, better than 94% of four-year colleges.
  • Strong pay: typical earnings ten years after starting are $82,742, higher than 89% of four-year colleges.
  • Debt is manageable: graduates owe a typical $18,000 in federal loans against earnings of $82,742.

Why it is bad

  • Expensive: the average student pays about $25,295 a year after grants, more than at 72% of four-year colleges.

The numbers

What these figures measure

Graduation rate: share of all students, full-time or part-time, who finish within 8 years. Return for year 2: share of first-time, full-time students who come back for a second year. Earnings: median pay about 10 years after starting, for students who received federal aid. Debt: median federal loan debt among those who finish. Net price: average yearly cost after grants and scholarships. All from the U.S. Education Department College Scorecard, institution file dated November 2, 2026.

Graduation rate
91%
Better than 96% of similar colleges. Typical: 59%
Return for year 2
97%
Better than 94% of similar colleges. Typical: 77%
Earnings after 10 years
$82,742
Better than 89% of similar colleges. Typical: $58,912
Debt at graduation
$18,000
Better than 88% of similar colleges. Typical: $21,609
Net price per year
$25,295
Better than 28% of similar colleges. Typical: $19,899
Published tuition
$72,069
Before any aid

Programs and early earnings

Bachelor's degrees: largest programs

FieldGraduates a yearEarnings, 2 yrs afterDebt
Computer Science80$76,460$20,917
Biology, General65$23,034$18,000
International Relations and National Security Studies40n/an/a
Mathematics39$37,568$19,916
Chemistry38$36,141$19,000
Economics37n/an/a
Research and Experimental Psychology29n/a$16,340
Fine and Studio Arts25$21,964n/a
English Language and Literature, General23$22,329n/a
Sociology and Anthropology23n/an/a
Statistics21n/an/a
Area Studies18n/an/a

Earnings are the median pay two years after completing, for graduates who were working and not enrolled again. The federal government hides figures for small programs, shown as n/a. Fields are broad groups, so a college may offer several majors inside one.

Students and reviews

Numbers cannot tell you about teaching, dorms or campus life. Read and write anonymous student reviews for Carleton College, or ask and answer questions about it. Other sources:

Compare with other colleges Estimate your cost

The grade reflects outcomes for the average student compared with other four-year colleges. Individual majors can be much better or worse.